Fight with Husband, not hunger: The reason behind UP woman throwing her five children in the river - FACTLY
Sai Krishna Muthyanolla
April 13, 2020
The news that a woman threw her five children into the Ganga river in Uttar Pradesh’s Bhadohi district is being shared widely on social media. It is being claimed that she threw her children because they had no food to eat during the current lockdown. Let’s analyze the claim made in the post.
A woman in UP threw her five children into the river as they had no food to eat during the current lockdown.
Fact: While it is true that a woman in UP had thrown her five children into the river, it is not due to the unavailability of food. The Bhadohi Police has clarified that the woman took such a drastic step after she quarrelled with her husband, not because of hunger. Hence the claim made in the post is FALSE.
The news – ‘No food during lockdown, mother throws 5 children into river’ was first published by ‘IANS’ (archived), which was later carried by other news agencies like ‘Outlook’ (archived), ‘Business Insider’ (archived) and India TV (archived)
Also, multiple people on social media [Prashant Bhushan (archived), Ashok Swain (archived), Rohan Gupta (archived). Brijesh Kalappa (archived) and Saba Naqvi (archived)] have tweeted the Outlook article with the same claim.
When we searched for more information on the incident, it was found that the Bhadohi Police has rubbished the false claim and clarified that the incident is not related to hunger. The woman threw her children due to a fight with her husband and out of mental stress.
@bhadohipolice मंजू देवी अपने पति के विवाद एवं मानसिक तनाव के कारण अपने पांचो बच्चों को गंगा नदी में डुबो दिया। मंजू देवी से पूछताछ की गई जिसमें पुलिस अधीक्षक भदोही द्वारा दी गई बाइट। pic.twitter.com/ThjyIHu6LW
The Bhadohi Police has also tweeted the woman’s video, where she mentions the fight with her husband.
@bhadohipolice मंजू देवी ने अपने  05 बच्चों को भूखमरी के कारण गंगा नदी में नहीं डुबाया है।अन्य कारण द्वारा घटना को अंजाम दिया गया है। मंजू देवी के बयान से स्पष्ट है कि भूखमरी के कारण बच्चों को नदी में नहीं डुबाया गया है।@Uppolice @adgzonevaranasi @digmirzapur pic.twitter.com/1vcMow8Kqh
The Bhadohi Police, in response to a tweet about the authenticity of the confession by the woman in police custody, has tweeted images of the food items present in the woman’s house.
मंजू देवी ने अपने  05 बच्चों को भूखमरी के कारण गंगा नदी में डुबो देने की बात गलत है मंजू देवी के घर में पर्याप्त मात्रा में खाद्य सामग्री थी। @Uppolice @adgzonevaranasi @digmirzapur pic.twitter.com/ZFNutl7Qy7
In order to check the authenticity of the claims made by the Bhadohi Police, with the available details of the children and the woman, when FACTLY looked for the ration details of the family on the Uttar Pradesh’s NFSA website, it was found that the family has taken a ration of 14 kg rice and 21 kg wheat on 08 March 2020 as per the NFSA norms.
To sum it up, fight with the husband, not hunger, is the reason behind UP woman throwing her five children in the river.
Did you watch our new video?