India’s RTI Act is the 4th Best in the World
Sai Krishna Muthyanolla
September 29, 2016
India’s RTI act is rated the 4th best in the world according to an annual rating of RTI like laws across the world. Pakistan’s law is at the 89th position, the worst in South Asia. Mexico is rated number one followed by Serbia and Slovenia.
India’s Right to Information (RTI) act that was passed in the year 2005 is widely hailed as one of the landmark legislations made after independence. While the implementation of the act has been a mixed bag, the act is considered by many, as a quality piece of legislation. Non-profits in the right to information advocacy space, Center for Law & Democracy & Access to Info Europe rate countries based on the quality of the RTI legislation every year. In the latest released rankings, on the eve of International Right to Know day, India is at the 4 place out of 111 countries that have a similar law. Mexico has now replaced Serbia as the top country in these ratings.
The Methodology
The Global Right to Information Rating comparatively assesses the strength of legal frameworks for the right to information from around the world. At the heart of the methodology for applying the RTI Rating are 61 Indicators. For each Indicator, countries earn points within a set range of scores (in most cases 0-2), depending on how well the legal framework delivers the Indicator, for a possible total of 150 points. The indicators are divided into seven different categories, namely: Right of Access, Scope, Requesting Procedures, Exceptions and Refusals, Appeals, Sanctions and Protections, and Promotional Measures.
Mexico on the Top
The most notable change in the latest rankings is the displacement of Serbia as the top country on the Rating for the first time since it was launched in 2011. Mexico has now replaced Serbia in the top spot. Mexico has substantially revamped its ‘General Act of Transparency and Access to Public Information’ and hence scored 136 points out of a possible total of 150. This is a significant improvement on their previous score of 117 and just ahead of Serbia, which scores 135 points.
Among the new countries that enacted the legislation, the strongest law was found to be that of Sri Lanka, which scored 121 points, putting it at 9 place globally. Every country in South Asia now has a RTI like legislation except Bhutan. The South Asian region is also a strong performer according to the new ratings with every country scoring over 100 points except Pakistan. Pakistan’s law scored only 66 points and is placed in the 89 position.
Five countries enacted a RTI like legislation in 2016 that includes Kenya, Philippines, Sri Lanka, Togo and Vietnam. Countries like Iran, Austria, Jordan, and Germany are in the bottom 10 of these rankings.
India at 4th position
India scored a total of 128 out of 150 points. While India scored well in terms of Right to Access, it lost 5 points in scope since the law exempts certain organizations from its ambit and also does not explicitly include private organizations that perform a public function. India also scored 25 out of 30 in requesting procedures since it is not free to file an application under RTI and the law does not mention anything about the unlimited reuse of information obtained through RTI. India’s RTI law scored 26 in the Exceptions category since the harm test is not applicable to all the exemptions mentioned in Section 8 of the RTI act. India scored the highest on appeals (29 out of 30). In the Sanctions category, India scored 5 out of the 8 since there is no strong legal protection for whistle blowers. India scored 13 out of 16 in the Promotional Measures category since there are no prescribed standards for record management and they are not followed in practice.